The top online savings accounts are paying about 4.35% this month, according to Bankrate's survey. Certificates of deposit go higher. CNBC Select's November list tops out at 5%, on terms that run from seven months to five years.

Those are good numbers. They are also less impressive than they look.

$20,000 in a 4.35% savings account for one year
Interest earned
+$870
Buying power lost to 4.2% inflation
−$840
Real gain, before taxes
$30

The 4.2% is KPMG's estimate for October. The government did not publish an official 12-month rate.

The part the bank's ad leaves out

Interest is only a gain if it outruns prices. Private economists estimate that consumer prices in October were about 4.2% higher than a year earlier. Against that, a 4.35% account is close to a draw: $870 of interest on $20,000, and $840 of lost buying power.

Then there are taxes. Savings interest is taxed as ordinary income. In the 22% federal bracket, $870 of interest becomes about $679 after tax, which is less than the $840 that inflation took. The money is safer in the account than anywhere else. It is not growing.

The comparison that matters is with the alternative. A big-bank savings account paying a fraction of a percent loses nearly the whole 4.2%. Getting to roughly even is worth the ten minutes it takes to open an account.

Lock a CD now, or wait for the Fed?

The Federal Reserve is expected to raise rates on December 9, and banks usually nudge deposit rates up afterward. That argues for waiting. The trouble is that nobody knows how many increases follow, and CD rates already reflect some of what is expected.

A few ways to avoid having to guess:

  • Split the money. Put a third in a 6-month CD, a third in a 12-month and a third in an 18-month. If rates rise, the short ones come due soon and can be reinvested higher. If rates fall, the long one is locked.
  • Read the early-withdrawal penalty. It is typically several months of interest. A small penalty makes it cheap to break the CD and move up if rates jump.
  • Consider a no-penalty CD. The rate is a little lower, and you can leave whenever you like.

The five-year CDs at 5% are a different kind of decision. Five years of compounding turns $20,000 into $25,526. That is a good outcome if inflation settles back toward 2% or 3%, and a poor one if it stays above 4%.

What belongs in savings and what does not

Cash in a savings account or CD is for money you will need within a few years and cannot afford to see fall: an emergency fund, a down payment, next year's tuition. For that job, a rate that matches inflation is a fine result.

It is the wrong place for money you will not touch for twenty years. Over long stretches, cash has barely kept up with prices, and this year is a typical example.

Two checks before you move money

Confirm that the bank is FDIC-insured, or NCUA-insured if it is a credit union. Coverage is $250,000 per depositor, per bank, per type of account.

And look at whether the headline rate is an introductory one. Some of the highest advertised numbers revert after a few months or require a linked checking account with direct deposit.

Sources for this story

This story is general information, not advice about your own money. Figures were checked against the sources above on Nov. 12, 2026. Spotted an error? Write to [email protected] and we will correct it in the open.