Suppose you have $10,000 you do not need this month. A bonus, an inheritance, or savings that have been sitting in a checking account. Here is what it would earn over the next year in eight places, from most to least.
- Paying off a credit card at 20%
- $2,000
- Series I savings bond, 5.51%
- $551
- Certificate of deposit, 5.00%
- $500
- 10-year Treasury note, 4.92%
- $492
- 1-year Treasury bill, 4.65%
- $465
- High-yield savings, 4.35%
- $435
- Dividend index fund, about 3.0%
- $300
- S&P 500 index fund, dividends only
- $107
Before taxes. The last two can also rise or fall in price; the others return what you put in if held to the end of the term.
1. Your own credit card: $2,000
The average credit card charges between 19.5% and 22.5% a year, depending on whose survey you use. Paying off $10,000 of card debt saves about $2,000 in interest over twelve months. That saving is certain, and it is not taxed.
Nothing else on the list comes close. If you carry a balance, the ranking ends here.
2. Series I savings bonds: $551
I bonds are sold by the Treasury and pay a rate tied to inflation. Bonds bought between now and April pay 5.51% for their first six months, built from a 1.40% fixed rate that lasts the life of the bond and an inflation component that resets twice a year.
The catches: you cannot cash out in the first year, you give up three months of interest if you cash out within five, and each person can buy $10,000 a year. The interest is free of state income tax.
3. A certificate of deposit: $500
The best CDs on CNBC Select's list this month pay 5.00%, on terms from seven months to five years. The rate is fixed and the deposit is federally insured up to $250,000. Leaving early costs a penalty, usually several months of interest.
4. A 10-year Treasury note: $492
The 10-year yielded 4.92% on Friday. A week earlier it was above 5.1%, near its highest in more than two decades, and it fell as investors moved out of stocks. Buy one and hold it to maturity and you collect that rate for ten years, whatever happens to interest rates.
If you sell early, the price depends on where rates are that day. If rates have risen, you would sell at a loss.
5. A one-year Treasury bill: $465
Shorter Treasuries pay less: 4.65% for one year and 4.14% for three months. The trade is flexibility. In a year you get your money back and can reinvest at whatever rates are then, which matters with the Fed expected to raise rates in December.
6. A high-yield savings account: $435
The top online accounts pay about 4.35%. The rate can change at any time, and the money is available whenever you want it. For an emergency fund, that access is worth more than the extra half-point a CD pays.
A caution that applies to items two through six: with inflation running near 4%, all of them are roughly holding their ground. None is making you much richer.
7. A dividend index fund: $300, plus or minus
The large dividend funds yield about 3%. The payments have tended to grow over time, and the shares can gain value. They can also lose it. In a bad year a fund like this can fall 20% or more.
8. An S&P 500 index fund: $107, plus or minus a lot
The index pays just 1.07% in dividends, near its record low. People do not buy it for the income. They buy it because over long periods its price has risen faster than anything else on this list. Over a single year it can do almost anything: it fell 37% in 2008, and it lost 8.6% in the single week that ended November 20.
So which one?
The ranking above is by income over the next twelve months, and for money you need within a few years that is the right way to rank. Items two through six all return your $10,000.
For money you will not touch for fifteen or twenty years, the order has historically run the other way, with stocks first and cash last. The price of that is living through years like 2008.
Most households need some of each. A common order of operations: clear card debt, collect any 401(k) match your employer offers, set aside a few months of expenses in savings, and only then decide how to split what is left between safe income and long-term growth.
Sources for this story
- Experian: current credit card interest rates
- TreasuryDirect: I bond interest rates
- Federal Reserve: H.15 selected interest rates
- CNBC Select: best CD rates, November 2026
- Bankrate: best high-yield savings accounts, November 2026
- Multpl: S&P 500 dividend yield
- 24/7 Wall St.: three dividend ETFs with over $10 billion each
This story is general information, not advice about your own money. Figures were checked against the sources above on Nov. 21, 2026. Spotted an error? Write to [email protected] and we will correct it in the open.